Wednesday, May 03, 2006

University cops promote web snitching for fun and profit

After the pro-democracy demonstrations in Tiananmen Square in 1989, the Chinese government broadcast surveillance camera footage and offered cash rewards for anyone willing to rat out individual protesters.

The University of Colorado at Boulder has taken a page out of the Communists' handbook and published surveillance photos online from a "smoke-in" style anti-drug war protest on April 20, aiming to identify and presumably prosecute the participants.


You get $50 apiece for snitching out your fellow students. Ugh! That's revolting to me, both that the university would do it and that anyone would participate to help identify folks. I've argued before that, while sometimes justified, snitching violates a number of
positive, right-thinking values that deserve more respect than the criminal justice system and the drug war often afford them.

I'm sure police believe publishing these photos on the web will serve a shaming function, punishing alleged offenders through public disgrace whether or not they can be convicted of anything (after all, who can prove what was in the depicted hand-rolled cigarettes?). But that's not law enforcement's role - judges and juries decide punishments in this country, not police.

If these aren't actually prosecutable cases, this tactic becomes nothing but thuggish harassment, no better, really, than what these guys are doing.
Certainly it's hard to argue that anything about this totalitarian exercise improves public safety.

Surely some people would report anyone they saw smoking pot to authorities; for them, the pay wouldn't change a thing. But if you wouldn't snitch without it, fifty bucks seems a grotesquely small sum for someone to be willing to trade their values, turn on their friends and become a rat.

Thanks to Daniel Bear for pointing me to this case.

10 comments:

SusanK said...

I like how you ran this item right after the one about the blue wall of silence. Maybe if internal affairs offered $50 a name, cops would be more willing to snitch on each other....

glenda said...

These brown shirt tactics are not working though, the tide is turning.
Change is in the air!

celtictexan said...

Sure young girls and boys who are molested by a family member or whatever should just keep it to themselves. Telling a child not to tattle and telling a witness to a murder or rape or whatever other felony are two way different things. Rape and taking a cookie thing's your articles make equal.

This article and attitude are both ridiculous and refect about as clear as anything I've seen the moral decline of the USA.

Gritsforbreakfast said...

Celtictexan, you're hilarious - you should take that act on the road, except Steven Colbert beat you to it. Oh wait, maybe that wasn't satire ...

Nobody here ever said witnesses to rape or murder shouldn't speak up. For example, in this post I wrote that "I never would tell someone who witnessed a violent crime, for example, not to report it." You're arguing against a beast of your own invention, not anything I've said.

How does red herring taste, anyway?

Anonymous said...

Hey, I know that one guy!

He's the son of one of the sicko idiots who thought up the idea to snitch out the students for 50 pieces of silver!

Kevin Schmidt, Sterling VA

Anonymous said...

Why bother with draconian U.S. drug laws?

Does your body belong to you or to the government? In Mexico, your body belongs to you!

Mexico just passed a new law making it leagal to posses small amounts of certain recreation drugs that are currently illegal in the U.S.!

The problem is, the legal limit of any one drug is quite small.

BUT, if you combine ALL the new legal amounts together at the same time, well then, NOW YOU HAVE A PART-AAAAA!!! The best part is, IT'S ALL PERFECTLY LEGAL!!!

Get your ass GONE WILD, south of the border and get your "PART-AAA PACK" today!

Rated AAAAA for Top Quality and Accurate, Predictable Dosages!

Each PARTY PACK includes the following FUN! FUN! FUN! Recreational drugs all perfectly legal in Mexico!:

1.) 25 milligrams of heroin
2.) fifth of an ounce of ganja (not associated with the Rasta religion)
3.) half a gram of cocaine
4.) 3 hits of LSD (not associated with the religion of Timothy deLearyism)
5.) 5 hallucinogenic mushrooms (not associated with Carlos Castenada or his "Journey To Ixtlan" where ever the hell that is.)
6.) 4 amphetamines
7.) 5 peyote buttons (not associated with the religion of PEYOTISM)

Seven steps to heaven! Guaranteed legal in Mexico!

Each PARTY PACK Guaranteed to to make you see God!!!

Help solve the immigration problem. Move to Mexico to replace the illegal guy who came to the U.S.!

KEVIN SCHMIDT, STERLING VA

rougy said...

Anti-drug people are such boobs. CU Boulder is one of the most beautiful places in the world. Pot has always been part of the culture, a laid-back, creative, culture of tolerance and progressiveness.

The CU cops have disgraced the school, the community, and most of all, themselves.

Anonymous said...

celtictexan - "liberals are liars" - what a pathetic little person you are.

Celtictexan said...

liberals are liars what is your point?

Anonymous said...

Take a look at the Eagle Companies 96 bed facilities. Gaurd to inmate rationis 48-1 safely.

They also lease these packages www.jailcells.com

Tim