Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Disbarment is readers' preferred punishment for lovebird judge and DA

Grits' week-long reader poll has ended and the results are in regarding what should be the punishment for Judge Verla Sue Holland and former Collin County DA Tom O'Connell, the pair of legal lovebirds from Collin County whose adulterous, years-long affair has left hundreds of cases in question.

One third of Grits readers, 33%, thought they should face criminal prosecution, while 45% said they should be disbarred. Only 15% said a public reprimand would be sufficient, while 6% said there should be no punishment because "it was a long time ago."

I personally voted with the group who believes Holland and O'Connell should be disbarred; in a past era I might even approve if they were tarred, feathered, and run out of town on a rail. But I see no sense in wasting a dime of taxpayer money to prosecute the pair.

An AP story today shows Grits readers aren't alone in finding the judge and prosecutor's behavior almost inconceivably stupid and harmful:
Legal experts are harshly criticizing a former judge and an ex-Texas prosecutor, saying their alleged sexual affair while handling cases together represents a black eye to the system.

"It's such incredible bad judgment because it throws every conviction into doubt," said Fred Moss, a Southern Methodist University law professor.

An apparent open secret 20 years ago in Collin County legal circles, the alleged affair became part of the public record again last week. ...

About 30 former prosecutors and federal and state judges have already signed a letter sent to Gov. Rick Perry arguing the alleged relationship had to be considered when it came to Hood, convicted in 1990 of fatally shooting two people in Plano.

The letter states that a sexual relationship, which Hood's lawyers say the judge and prosecutor acknowledged under oath during depositions last week, "would have had a significant impact on the ability of the judicial system to accord Mr. Hood a fair and impartial trial." ...

"The appearance of impropriety is absolutely there and it does affect the integrity of the system," said Rick Hagen, president of the Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association. "And you can't deny that." ...

Neither Holland nor O'Connell have been publicly disciplined by the State Commission on Judicial Conduct or the State Bar of Texas. ...

Moss said he expects the appeals court to find a reason to grant a new trial for Hood, who was convicted of killing a 26-year-old former dancer and her 46-year-old boyfriend.

"What it does is bring the whole system into question," Moss said. "It's a real black eye to the system and very unfortunate. It shakes the confidence of the public in the criminal justice system."

All that said, Grits reader poll question asked only what SHOULD happen to Holland and O'Connell. If asked what WILL happen, my own prediction would be "nothing." No public reprimand, much less disbarment, and no prosecutor will ever even crack the lawbooks looking for possible charges. The Court of Criminal Appeals will grant Hood relief based on other grounds, if I had to predict, conveniently avoiding any formal inquiry that would further embarrass their former colleague.

Maybe that's too cynical, but how cynical was it for the judge and DA to remain mum about their affair hoping Hood would be executed to cover up their misconduct? In an environment where this kind of behavior is blatantly tolerated at the courthouse and overlooked in the appellate courts on a death penalty case, I'm not sure you can be too cynical. I'd love to be proven wrong.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

The DA and Judges are all "in bed together"! The only way the plea deal process works is the Judges agree to "throw the book" at anyone that does not accept a deal.

95% of the accused take a deal. I seriously doubt that 95% are innocent. The system gets away with this cozy arrangement between Prosecutors and Judges every day.

Why would they change anything now?

Anonymous said...

Maybe that's too cynical, but how cynical was it for the judge and DA to remain mum about their affair hoping Hood would be executed to cover up their misconduct?


It would be a lot worse if there was any chance in hell that Hood was wrongly convicted. He wasn't.

Gritsforbreakfast said...

"It would be a lot worse "

You ain't seen nothing yet, pal. They've opened Pandora's Box. There are hundreds of convictions that will now be revisited, whether or not they were wrongly convicted. It WILL be a lot worse. And it's nobody's fault but Holland and O'Connell.

Anonymous said...

I'd like to see the county go after both of them in a civil suit for the costs associated with this mess.

Soronel Haetir said...

The problem I see with disbarment is that afaik both of these people are no longer practicing. What kind of punishment is it to say you can no longer do something you aren't doing anyway?

Anonymous said...

If they broke the law, then prosecute them. But disbarment is part of the larger trend of making a person pay an extra-legal penelty for the rest of their life with regards to employment. It's unfair, it's wrong. If they are convicted and pay the price, they should be able to re-enter society without being cheap labor for the rest of their life. After all, if a person should pay for the rest of their life for every infraction of the law, why not just sentence everyone to life in prison and be honest about the fact that the Texas prison system is set up as a modern system of slavery ?

Anonymous said...

The problem I see with disbarment is that afaik both of these people are no longer practicing. What kind of punishment is it to say you can no longer do something you aren't doing anyway?

Part of the deal could be that they give up their pensions.

That'll hurt plenty. Just ask Judge Block, from Houston.

Anonymous said...

HEY GRITS, When are you going to look into the Russian defendant in Bexar County who was denied an interpreter by Judge Roman who was cavorting/joking around with the male ADA in the 175th District Court on a Capital Murder case last year? The appeal was granted for a retrial!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Look into it please......

Anonymous said...

Tell me how Hood's life became so important that 30 former prosecutors and federal and state judges sent a letter to Gov. Rick Perry arguing the alleged relationship had to be considered when it came to Hood.
What was in it for them?

Anonymous said...

I like to play Asda Story, because I like its name, also I like Asda Story gold. My friend told me that she would buy Asda Story money for me, and I was so happy. I do not like to go shopping, because it always spends a lot of money, but I never hesitate to buy Asda Story Gold. You can buy cheap Asda Story gold; it is so easy and convenient.