Sunday, September 21, 2008

Pro-jail bond committee created in Tyler

In Tyler, a pro-jail committee will announce itself Monday in support of Smith County's third jail bond ballot in three years, reports the Morning Telegraph:
The "Finally! A Jail Plan We Can Afford Committee" will hold a news conference announcing the formation of its action group in support of the Smith County Jail Bond proposed Nov. 4.

Former jail opposition leader Bobby Curtis and past jail proposition supporter Herb Buie, along with Treasurer Harold Beaird and Campaign Manager Sharon Guthrie make up the committee that will lobby for the passage of the $59 million jail bond.

The press conference will take place inside the Smith County Annex Building Court Room at 200 E. Ferguson 11 a.m. on Monday.
I'd reported earlier on the creation of Tyler's local jail opposition group, the "What part of no don't you understand committee." With nine figures of school bonds also on the ballot in Tyler and a high turnout election with the presidential race on the ballot, I have a hard time imagining how local officials think a jail vote will pass now when it was rejected by 2/3 of the voters two years running.

Tyler District Judge Cynthia Kent predicts the jail will be full on the day it opens because the commissioners court remains too focused on new construction instead of diverting people from jail or processing cases more quickly through the courts. Smith County has created a couple of successful diversion programs in light of recent jail bond rejections, but by all appearances the only way to get them to fully commit to that strategy would be for voters to reject the jail for the third year running. I predict that's exactly what will happen.

Friday, September 19, 2008

Rape victim seeks court to clear the name of now-deceased man she misidentified

A Texas rape victim is working to clear the name of the man convicted of attacking her. Michele Mallin of Baytown is traveling to Fort Worth today to meet with the family of Timothy Cole, a Lubbock man convicted of raping her who was posthumously cleared by DNA. She told the Fort Worth Star Telegram ("A rape victim is working to clear the name of the dead man convicted of attacking her," Sept. 19):

"I felt total guilt. My words. My pointing the finger at him, were the reason he went to prison," Mallin said. "I felt just terrible. . . . I never wanted the wrong man to be convicted. I hope everyone knows that."

Back then a 20-year-old Texas Tech sophomore, Mallin was a woman on a mission, determined to send Cole — nicknamed the "Tech Rapist" — to prison. Now, at 43, she is equally determined to clear Coles’ name, making him the first posthumous exoneration by DNA in Texas.

She will meet with Cole’s mother and brothers today in Fort Worth and will work with their attorney in filing a petition next week seeking a court of inquiry to clear Coles’ name.

Ruby Session, Cole’s 71-year-old mother, is looking forward to meeting Mallin.

"I don’t blame her. We don’t blame her. We never did," Session said. "Because she is a victim, too. She was victimized. She and Tim were the victims." ...

"I thought this family probably hates me. He can’t, but they must," Mallin said. "I couldn’t believe that they wanted to talk to me or see me. They were very gracious and nice people. They said they didn’t blame me."

Mallin's participation with Cole's family emphasizes how doubly harmful it is when an innocent person is convicted, since that also means the guilty person won't be punished. I really admire her reaction to this terrible scenario and her willingness to work with Cole's family.

Just as there's no real process for courts to review post-conviction actual innocence claims in cases with no DNA, there's also not an established way for courts to clear the name of innocent people where the wrongfully convicted defendant has died. The Innocence Project of Texas (Disclosure: for whom I work as a policy consultant) has taken on Cole's case and is pursuing a legal strategy to posthumously exonerate him that will next take Cole's family and Mallin to Austin:

Jeff Blackburn, chief counsel for the Innocence Project of Texas, said he plans to go to Travis County to seek the court of inquiry after being rejected by a Lubbock County judge in early August.

"What they want, and Michele Mallin wants, is a judge in some court in this state to finally tell it like it is and set the record straight," Blackburn said. "Only that will clear his name and provide some closure for Michele."

Hurricane News

TCJS heads to Galveston. Texas Commission on Jail Standards Chief Adan Munoz is headed down to Galveston today to check on the deputies and inmates who've been stranded in the county jail after Hurricane Ike without electricity, working toilets or running water.

Victoria jail still evacuated. It sounds like the Sheriff's emergency jail plans in Victoria were a lot smarter than in Galveston. They released 200 non-violent offenders prior to the storm and moved the rest to safety 36-48 hours before the hurricane hit. They're temporarily refusing to accept low-level arrestees in the Victoria jail until everyone gets re-settled, something which happened for a more extended period with apparently no ill effects in Chambers and Gregg Counties after Hurricane Rita.

Waiting to make bond. Texas City finally brought in a bond company Wednesday to get petty offenders out of their municipal jail who'd been kept there since before the storm. I don't know why they didn't release non-violent misdemeanants prospectively like in Victoria.

Sex offenders rounded up from evacuation shelters. The SA Express News reports that "About 1,000 sex offender parolees displaced by Hurricane Ike have been rounded up and sent to prisons and jails across the state." In Austin, police simply evicted sex offenders from evacuation shelters. “I have no idea where they went (after being put out) but they're not allowed to come back,” said James Mason, an Austin police detective. An ACLU analyst called Austin's policy "mystifying," declaring, “It's the opposite of keeping track of people.”

Another Dallas DNA Exoneree

Yet another Dallas exoneree will walk free this morning after spending 26 years in a Texas prison on a false rape conviction thanks to newly tested DNA evidence that cleared him.

This is another terrible case of misidentification by an eyewitness. Believe it or not, a witness actually picked Johnnie Lindsey out of a photo lineup that was mailed to her a year after the incident! Lindsey's "was one of two pictures that showed a shirtless man, a description given by the victim immediately after the attack," according to a summary of the case issued by the Innocence Project of Texas which represented Lindsey at his findings hearing.

It was also an instance where investigators and jurors discounted strong alibi evidence that "included a timecard for the day of the attack and testimony by Johnnie’s boss that his absence would have shut down their commercial laundry operation on that day."

Dallas has seen so many innocent men leaving prison recently the effect can become numbing. Blogger Trey Garrison offered these bon mots when the DNA results were announced, "Yet another Henry Wade era conviction is overturned on DNA evidence. Or as we call it in Dallas, a Tuesday."

Johnnie Lindsey is the 19th Dallas man proven innocent and freed from prison through DNA evidence and the 35th Texan overall.

Around the blogs

Several recent posts from other blogs deserve Grits readers attention, starting with Texas Prison Bidness which has these private prison-related nuggets:
At Dallas Sidebar, Proximo wonders why the Dallas County Commissioners Court thinks they get to micromanage activities of other elected officials. I've wondered that, too.

At the Friends of Justice blog, Lydia Bean offers a thoughtful post on the New Testament book of Philemon and its relevance to modern civil rights struggles.

The Deception Blog has an excellent post on using MRI brain scans for purposes of lie detection, concluding that recent arguments that such technology may soon be reliable enough to become admissible in US courts are "way off-beam."

Thursday, September 18, 2008

'Move along, nothing to see here,' says FBI on anthrax attacks

Pat Leahy, one of the US senators targeted in the 2001 anthrax attacks, made this shocking declaration yesterday that he doesn't believe Bruce Ivins, the scientist blamed for the attacks who committed suicide earlier this year, acted alone:
"If he is the one who sent the letter, I do not believe in any way, shape or manner that he is the only person involved in this attack on Congress and the American people," Leahy told FBI Director Robert S. Mueller III at a hearing yesterday. "I believe there are others involved, either as accessories before or accessories after the fact. I believe that there are others who can be charged with murder."
Noting that GOP senator and former prosecutor Arlen Specter joined Leahy in aggressively discounting the FBIs claims, telling Mueller that the case wouldn't pass muster in a criminal trial, Glenn Greenwald at Salon summed up the import of the hearing:

The bottom line is that it is quite extraordinary that the FBI has claimed it has identified with certainty the sole culprit in the anthrax attacks, but so many key Senators, from both parties, simply don't believe it, and are saying so explicitly. Leahy's rather dark suggestion that there were others involved in these attacks -- likely at a U.S. Army facility or key private CIA contractor -- is particularly notable. It has been crystal clear from the beginning that the FBI's case is filled with glaring holes, that their thuggish behavior towards their only suspect drove him to commit suicide and thus is unable to defend himself, and yet, to this day, the FBI continues to conceal the evidence in its possession and is stonewalling any and all efforts to scrutinize its claims.

It takes a lot for Senators from both parties to so openly and explicitly say they don't believe the FBI's definitive accusations in such a high-profile case.
Indeed, it does!

These matters can get particularly dicey for the FBI when a primary crime victim is also the chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee! Rightly or wrongly, Leahy's in a position to insist that they show their work when otherwise, clearly, they'd rather call the case closed and forget about it.

See prior, related Grits posts:

Blogger wants Collin County to follow Dallas in reviewing capital cases

Upon observing that Dallas County District Attorney Craig Watkins this week told the press he wanted to re-examine about 40 death penalty cases from Dallas County, Bill Baumbach at the Collin County Observer said the Charles Hood and Michael Blair cases show a similar review is needed in his county, offering this blog-cry in the wilderness about the damage recent incidents have caused to pubic confidence in the courts:

Collin County is well known for its no-nonsense harsh sentences and vigorous prosecution of evil doers. Unfortunately, it appears that, at least some of the time, our zeal to convict has overrun our sense of justice.

Our notion that all defendants are innocent until proven guilty in a fair trial is one of the glues that holds our society together. Most of us don't fear our courts, because we are confident that even if we are wrongly charged, the truth will prevail.

When that confidence is lost, we no longer live under the rule of law, but the rule of men - men who wish us harm.

In a letter to DA Roach on the Hood case, Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott wrote, "... a death sentence is most serious and solemn act of any state. The impartiality of a defendant's trial and conviction must be beyond reproach."

As important as the notion of a fair trial is the unavoidable problem that when an innocent man is convicted, a guilty criminal is left free to commit new crimes - to hurt more victims.

Beyond those high-profile cases, he said, "Judicial and prosecutorial zeal has caused the recusal of another Collin County judge in the case of Mark Bell," an incident I hadn't heard about.

While I share Baumbach's sentiment that these cases show something may be deeply wrong with Collin County justice, asking John Roach to review these cases is a lot different from Craig Watkins doing it in Dallas. There are reviews and then there are reviews.

One facet of Watkins decision I found interesting was when the man he beat in the DA's race, Republican Toby Shook, complained to the Dallas News, "Perhaps he hasn't thought this through, but essentially what he's saying is, 'There is one more court of appeal and that's me."

That's a clever way to phrase it, but it's not really what's happening. The DA has a role in when executions get set and his office is exercising its prerogative. Instead, Watkins is issuing a no-confidence vote on the work of his predecessors at the Dallas DA's office, including Shook, in light of the rising tide of successful actual innocence claims.

Michael Blair's exoneration shows that even in death penalty cases the system can make mistakes and get the verdict 100% wrong, with appellate courts routinely approving even obvious mistakes. Watkins is right to want to identify and correct any errors before they become irreversible.

Missing ATF laptops bigger concern than stolen guns

Federal ATF agents misplaced 76 firearms and hundreds of laptops in the last five years according to a recent audit, AP reports. While we see weapons at police agencies show up missing rather frequently, I'm especially interested in what's becoming an even more widespread problem of lost or stolen law enforcement laptops, in this case at ATF. Most went unreported and nobody knows whether they contained critical case information, identities of informants or undercover agents, or just downloaded porn:
ATF employees did not report 13 of the 76 lost weapons, or 365 of the 418 missing laptops, to internal affairs as required. ATF officials also did not report much of the lost equipment to the Justice Department.

Investigators could not conclude what was on 398 of 418 missing laptops — except that few were encrypted. That means any sensitive material on the laptops could have been exposed.

Moreover, "we found that ATF did not regularly attempt to determine whether the lost, stolen or missing laptop computers contained sensitive or classified information," the audit said.

A few years ago a DEA agent had a laptop stolen containing personal information about 100 confidential informants and thousands of pages of internal case files. That could have also happened with ATF, except that auditors have no idea what was on 95% of the missing laptops.

That's a bigger deal than the missing guns, IMO. Crooks can buy firearms anywhere, but information compiled on an ATF investigator's computer might be a particularly valuable commodity.

Nobody knows for sure if any of these laptops fell into the hands of organized crime, but at least two of the guns wound up in the hands of crooks:
Two weapons reported stolen were used to commit crimes. In one instance, a gun was stolen from an ATF car parked outside the agent's home and later used to shoot through the window of another residence, the audit found. In the other, a stolen ATF gun was taken from a burglary suspect.
So if some of the weapons wind up in the hands of criminals, it's a good bet the same is true for at least some percentage of ATF's missing laptops.

RELATED: From Bruce Schneier, "UK Ministry of Defense loses memory stick with military secrets."

Exoneration shows sex offender registration based on faulty premise

During the legislative process when it first passed, Texas' sex offender registration statute was dubbed "Ashley's Law," named after 7-year old Ashley Estell who was raped and murdered in Collin County in 1993. Authorities at the time decided a man named Michael Blair committed the crime, targeting him in part because he'd been convicted previously of a sex offense.

As it turned out, though Blair was no angel, he had nothing to do with Ashley Estell's death. DNA tests this year cleared Blair - who had been sent to death row for the crime - and identified a culprit who died ten years ago without ever being prosecuted for the offense. This week the courts finally dismissed the case against Blair, reports AP. (Though leaving death row he remains in prison for other offenses he admitted to while behind bars.)

The collapse of the case against Blair shows the wrong thinking behind modern sex offender registration laws, which make public information about offenders' past criminal history and portray this as having predictive value as to whether people should fear them. As in Blair's case, though, that can backfire if sex offender registration causes police and the public to develop a "round up the usual suspects" mentality.

The premise behind Texas' sex offender registration laws was that if Ashley's family could have known about Blair's past they could possibly have better protected their child. Except that since Blair didn't do it, his case instead shows how widely distributing that knowledge can lead to wrongful persecution and prosecution. As a result, the real killer was never held accountable. As I've written previously, "to the extent [Texas' registration] laws arose from lessons learned in the Ashley Estell case, they were literally based in error from their inception."

The worst part: That error produces more crime and more victims. Research shows that sex offender registration can
increase recidivism for those on the registry "by imposing social and financial costs on registered sex offenders and making non-criminal activity relatively less attractive."

DNA evidence has been an incredibly valuable tool, not only for solving old cases but providing a window onto a variety of common errors in the justice system from faulty eyewitness ID procedures to unregulated use of informants and shoddy forensic techniques. With Blair's case we can add the premises behind sex offender registration laws to the list of errors identified post facto thanks to DNA evidence.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Dallas nixes verified response for commercial burglar alarms

The Dallas City Council earlier this month last year foolishly rejected Police Chief David Kunkle's highly successful initiative to require verification for commercial burglar alarms before sending police to respond. Mayor Tom Leppert pushed the council to vote 10-4 to overturn the nearly two-year old policy, despite the fact that it saved the department money, reduced fines on local businesses and enabled DPD to improve other services, all while burglaries declined.

More than 97% of commercial alarms in Dallas turn out to be false and of those that are real police almost never arrive in time to catch anyone in the act. For home alarms that figure is even higher.

Burglar alarm services sold by private companies are a classic example of "security theater." They make people feel safer but don't make it any less likely your home will be burglarized or that police will catch the person who robbed you.

What's more, the business model schlepps actual costs of providing the service onto taxpayers who pay for the cops who show up and mill around after each alarm goes off. The security company does nothing for their income but install the alarm system and call 911 when it's activated.

Bottom line: 911 is for emergencies and burglar alarms almost never qualify as such, but in many jurisdictions they're the single most common type of police service call.

According to the Dallas News ("Dallas police to respond to business burglar alarms," Sept. 7):

Wednesday's vote comes 21 months after the council voted 8-5 to institute verified response for businesses, with Mayor Laura Miller arguing: "I believe in the chief. This makes sense."

With the repeal, Mr. Leppert, who took office in June, scored his first major political victory on a contentious item before the council.

As recently as last week, Mayor Pro Tem Elba Garcia said she believed she had enough votes to reaffirm verified response, which Mr. Leppert placed on the council's agenda for a vote.

But Mr. Leppert persuaded council colleagues who remained undecided earlier this month to ultimately repeal the policy.

The policy shift also is redemption for a local alarm industry that's relentlessly lobbied council members since verified response became law in Dallas.

Dr. Garcia decried Wednesday's decision, saying it hurls Dallas back to the situation it found itself in earlier this decade, when hundreds of police officer work hours were wasted responding to false burglar alarms.

"Today's choice is whether we back up our chief of police and the Dallas Police Department and continue to prepare to protect citizens from harm, or we cave in to the alarm industry," Dr. Garcia said.

"It's about the utilization of a scarce resource," District 5 council member Vonciel Jones Hill said. "Verified response has worked the way it was intended to work. It does not make sense to continue to send a scarce resource to false alarms when we have higher priorities."

District 14 council member Angela Hunt said: "Our police chief helped us use our scarce resources ... to their highest and best use. Why are we taking them off the street? Why are we taking them out of our neighborhoods to cater to false alarms? We should listen to [Chief Kunkle's] guidance and not be swayed by politics."

Between February 2006 and March 2007, Dallas experienced a 45 percent reduction in burglar alarm calls and redirected $1.56 million in manpower costs previously spent on responding to false alarms to other work, according to the city staff's briefing to the council. It also noted that fees charged for false alarms decreased by $1.19 million.

Business burglaries declined by 0.6 percent during a one-year period that ended Feb. 28, according to the presentation to the council.

Dr. Garcia offered a substitute motion to shelve Wednesday's vote and direct the council's newly constituted Public Safety Committee, of which she is chairwoman, to further study verified response.

But her motion failed, and Mr. Leppert called for a vote on the original motion.

The council's decision is effective Oct. 1.

The Dallas City Council should be going the other direction, requiring verified response for home alarms as well. Instead their decision will reduce police coverage and increase response time for more serious calls. I'm sure the Dallas Council isn't planning to hire more officers to make up the difference.

Mayor Tom Leppert said, "We've got to be concerned about the policy and the wider message it sends." But what message is that, exactly? To me it's basically, "We'd rather make the general public less safe in order to subsidize private alarm companies who profit from selling fear instead of using police resources for fighting crime."

Is that really the message they want to be sending?

CORRECTION: The original post mistakenly said this change was made earlier this month. In fact, Dallas' verfied response ended one year ago and the Dallas News blog post I was reacting to was reporting, instead, on a new proposal by Dallas to ask the Legislature to give cities authority to fine people after the first false alarm. Sorry about the mixup.

UPDATE: A reader sent me data on Salt Lake City's verified alarm system, which appears to work great and save the city a lot of money. According to a handout from the Salt Lake PD I received via email:
The Verified Response ordinance became effective on December 1, 2000. Our department immediately experienced an unprecedented 90% reduction in alarm responses. Past efforts to reduce the volume of false alarms through permits, warnings, fines and suspensions had only a modest effect. Police response to alarms was most effective and efficient when it was first verified that alarm activation was indicative of suspicious activity. Private security guards are ideally suited to make this initial verification. Police continue to respond to human-activated alarms such as robbery, panic and duress which continue to be 99% false.

In the first year, Verified Response freed 8,482 officer hours which could then be redirected to other police priorities and also saved $508,920 in associated personnel costs. ...

Verified Response has been a win-win for our citizens and our department. Due to the low priority of alarm signals, private guard response time to alarm activations has been much quicker than police response. Police have been able to reduce the response time to high priority emergency calls, including panic, robbery and duress alarms, by nearly one minute. Most citizens will pay as little as an additional $5 per month on their monitoring account for guard response, rather than the former $100 false alarm fines. Most importantly, our officers were able to redirect time spent on answering false alarm signals to other public safety concerns.

Major Gulf Cartel Bust

The Dallas News Crime Blog brings welcome news that:
A 15-month investigation cracking down on one of Mexico's largest drug cartels resulted in the arrests of 175 suspects yesterday and today, 22 of them in North Texas.

So far, Project Reckoning has led to more than 500 arrests and the seizure of $60 million and more than 40 tons of drugs, U.S. Attorney General Michael Mukasey announced today.

Those indicted include three alleged leaders of the Gulf cartel: Ezequiel Cardenas-Guillen, Heriberto Lazcano-Lazcano (right) and Jorge Eduardo Costilla-Sanchez. ...

The international investigation was centered in Atlanta, but attorneys in the Northern District of Texas are handling some of the cases. More details on the local efforts to come.
One wonders if these North Texas arrests are related in any way to the Gulf Cartel snitch found working in a Collin County constable's office earlier this year?

Today's arrests also contained an Italian connection. According to the USDOJ press release:
Today’s operation also involved significant cooperation from Italy, for which I thank Dr. Gratteri. Among those charged in today’s indictments are members of an organized crime group based in Calabria, Italy, who allegedly sold cocaine supplied by the Gulf Cartel via New York. The Italian government’s firm commitment to combat drug trafficking is evident in the success of this operation.
I remain convinced that these multinational smuggling operations are a greater threat to US security than any Muslim terrorist, certainly for us here in Texas. The cartels have gone far beyond drugs to smuggling every type of black market contraband from crop pickers to sex workers to Asian porn, stolen cigarettes and anything else someone wants to sneak across the border.

It remains to be seen what kind of dent this makes in Gulf Cartel operations or whether their competitors move in to take over their turf.

Disbarment is readers' preferred punishment for lovebird judge and DA

Grits' week-long reader poll has ended and the results are in regarding what should be the punishment for Judge Verla Sue Holland and former Collin County DA Tom O'Connell, the pair of legal lovebirds from Collin County whose adulterous, years-long affair has left hundreds of cases in question.

One third of Grits readers, 33%, thought they should face criminal prosecution, while 45% said they should be disbarred. Only 15% said a public reprimand would be sufficient, while 6% said there should be no punishment because "it was a long time ago."

I personally voted with the group who believes Holland and O'Connell should be disbarred; in a past era I might even approve if they were tarred, feathered, and run out of town on a rail. But I see no sense in wasting a dime of taxpayer money to prosecute the pair.

An AP story today shows Grits readers aren't alone in finding the judge and prosecutor's behavior almost inconceivably stupid and harmful:
Legal experts are harshly criticizing a former judge and an ex-Texas prosecutor, saying their alleged sexual affair while handling cases together represents a black eye to the system.

"It's such incredible bad judgment because it throws every conviction into doubt," said Fred Moss, a Southern Methodist University law professor.

An apparent open secret 20 years ago in Collin County legal circles, the alleged affair became part of the public record again last week. ...

About 30 former prosecutors and federal and state judges have already signed a letter sent to Gov. Rick Perry arguing the alleged relationship had to be considered when it came to Hood, convicted in 1990 of fatally shooting two people in Plano.

The letter states that a sexual relationship, which Hood's lawyers say the judge and prosecutor acknowledged under oath during depositions last week, "would have had a significant impact on the ability of the judicial system to accord Mr. Hood a fair and impartial trial." ...

"The appearance of impropriety is absolutely there and it does affect the integrity of the system," said Rick Hagen, president of the Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association. "And you can't deny that." ...

Neither Holland nor O'Connell have been publicly disciplined by the State Commission on Judicial Conduct or the State Bar of Texas. ...

Moss said he expects the appeals court to find a reason to grant a new trial for Hood, who was convicted of killing a 26-year-old former dancer and her 46-year-old boyfriend.

"What it does is bring the whole system into question," Moss said. "It's a real black eye to the system and very unfortunate. It shakes the confidence of the public in the criminal justice system."

All that said, Grits reader poll question asked only what SHOULD happen to Holland and O'Connell. If asked what WILL happen, my own prediction would be "nothing." No public reprimand, much less disbarment, and no prosecutor will ever even crack the lawbooks looking for possible charges. The Court of Criminal Appeals will grant Hood relief based on other grounds, if I had to predict, conveniently avoiding any formal inquiry that would further embarrass their former colleague.

Maybe that's too cynical, but how cynical was it for the judge and DA to remain mum about their affair hoping Hood would be executed to cover up their misconduct? In an environment where this kind of behavior is blatantly tolerated at the courthouse and overlooked in the appellate courts on a death penalty case, I'm not sure you can be too cynical. I'd love to be proven wrong.

Galveston jail unprepared for Ike aftermath

When the Galveston Sheriff chose to make jail inmates and deputies ride out Hurricane Ike despite warnings to evacuate or face "certain death," the justification was that the jail was on high ground and built to withstand hurricane force winds.

That overlooked two important factors: First, the main risk was flooding; fortunately the worst of Ike barely missed Galveston, but here's the official pre-storm prediction of how a worst-case scenario would have engulfed the jail along with the rest of the island had it happened. (The blog Facing South has an update including post-storm pictures of the jail released yesterday by the Sheriff.)

Second, and this is the problem they're struggling with now - once the storm has passed the jail is stranded in a disaster area with no electricity, running water or working toilets, reported the Houston Chronicle:
"We've been trying to get some power hooked up inside the justice center," [jail architect Dudley] Anderson said. "There's a small one in there now, but they need power." ...

Anderson said the only generator in the jail this morning was supplying a small operator area. He had another generator ready to help a bit with air flow, but the large generators expected from the federal government are what he's frustrated about. ...

Anderson said that, without air circulating in the closed facility in this climate, mold and mildew can start growing everywhere. The lack of water and properly working toilet facilities exacerbates the problem, he said. ...

Anderson said that, despite his frustration, he has had cooperation from two fronts: the weather and the inmates.

He said some of the inmates helped him repair the small generator that works in the control area.

And, he said, without the good weather these past few days, the jail area would be in a far worse situation.

It's certainly good news that no one was hurt during the storm at the jail, but that still doesn't make leaving the inmates there a good idea and this story shows why. Just like after Hurricane Katrina, the devastating aftermath in Galveston will continue for quite a while after the storm surge has officially passed. Any idiot could have predicted there would be no electricity and a "lack of water and properly working toilet facilities" at the jail. (A local church is providing charity packages for jailers, but not for inmates.)

Galveston officials are complaining to the press that FEMA hasn't reacted quickly enough to bail them out of their bad decision, but FEMA didn't force the Sheriff to keep his jailers and inmates on the island contrary to evacuation warnings, particularly when his jail doen't have sufficient generators to keep the lights on or air circulation flowing.

Staying on the island wasn't a very wise choice on the Sheriff's part. As I wrote on Friday, many Galveston inmates were sitting in jail awaiting trial or for low-level offenses who could have been released if the county had planned ahead. The rest should have been moved, just like they did with TDCJ inmates and at other coastal jails. Although the threat from the storm has passed, Galveston Island remains essentially uninhabitable and everyone pretty much knew it would be that way at the time the Sheriff made the decision not to move the inmates.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

A closer look at the 'Missouri model' for juvie corrections

During the height of last year's debates over what should happen at the Texas Youth Commission, the state of the art best practices legislators were most often encouraged to follow - including by a "blue ribbon commission" appointed by the Governor - came from the "Missouri model," which was used as a catch phrase to describe a range of reforms that generally promoted smaller facilities and more therapeutic, less prison-like approaches.

Since that time reforms in Texas have moved a long way from the Missouri model, but the St. Louis Post Dispatch offered a story to at least remind us of what Texas should be aiming for ("Missouri leads nation in juvenile justice reform," Sept. 13). The approach at first blush sounds like it would be criticized reflexively as "soft on crime," except that it achieves anti-recidivism results that won over even the most hard-nosed cynics in Missouri. Reports the Post-Dispatch, tracking the story of a single inmate:
Instead of being imprisoned like a criminal, he became a kid again.

Instead of cell bars and handcuffs, he was given a tidy dorm room, stuffed animals and even a pet turtle. Instead of shame, he was given group therapy, school work, job training and a support group of 10 peers led by a therapist — not a prison guard.

It is that approach to juvenile delinquency, dubbed the "Missouri Model," that garnered the Missouri Division of Youth Services last week the 2008 Annie E. Casey Innovations Award in Children and Family System of Reform. The award, administered by Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government, comes with a $100,000 prize to promote the model.

Judges commended the program for its staying power, its current push to link its programs with community advisory boards and its growing influence on juvenile justice nationwide.

So far, Missouri has hosted visitors from 30 states seeking to overhaul juvenile systems in which recidivism and suicide rates are high, and where youths are often written off as hardened criminals.
It took political courage, initially, to launch the Missouri program, but now that it's been in place for a while, the numbers tell the tale: Their recidivism rates were just 8% over three years compared with 30% in Maryland, which has a similar sentencing scheme and more traditional youth prisons like Texas.

TYC is at least lurching toward smaller facilities, to some extent, but not as small as the ones in Missouri, except for a few halfway houses, and not with the same therapeutic approach. And if TYC caseloads increase, the pressure to revert to larger facilities to warehouse delinquent youth could become overwhelming.

All this to say, the Missouri model may be too lofty a goal for Texas to reasonably strive for in the current environment, but reading this Post-Dispatch story will at least give readers a sense of what Texas' best experts (pdf) told the Lege they should be shooting for during the 80th Legislature, whether or not it's achievable.

On jailhouse snitches and access to courts for non-DNA innocence claims

A long list of DNA-based exonerations in recent years have overturned the convictions of innocent people locked up in prison, sometimes for decades. The reasons are pretty consistent - mistaken witness identification, faulty forensic evidence, prosecutors withholding exculpatory evidence, false confessions, and lying snitches cause the bulk of cases where innocents are convicted.

But DNA evidence exists in just 10% of violent crimes and even more rarely in other cases. And while Texas law allows for post-conviction DNA testing if the evidence exists, there's no mechanism for evaluating innocence in non-DNA cases where these same problems arise.

A situation involving a mendacious jailhouse snitch out of Orange, Texas shows how such cases play out when DNA evidence doesn't exist to prove innocence to a certainty. KPRC-Channel 2 in Houston recently told the story of Daniel Meehan (Sept. 4) whose 1998 conviction and 99-year sentence was based in part on testimony by an informant who now says he lied to get his own cases dismissed and that prosecutors told him what to say:
Despite the strong circumstantial evidence he was the killer, Meehan maintained he did not do it. In 1998, he pled not guilty and the case went to trial inside an Orange County courtroom."

About that time, their star witness came along that kind of saved the day for them is what it seemed like," said Meehan. "Because he seemed to be their case."He was Gary Harris -- a fellow inmate inside the Orange County jail.

When District Attorney John Kimbrough called Harris to the stand, Harris testified Meehan had confessed to the murder behind bars -- describing how he shot his girlfriend point-blank, saying, "I can't have her, no one can."

"When he looked at the jury and said that statement, you know, it blew me away," Meehan said. "It really did. I was 31 years old and I was thinking, 'My life is over.'"The jury convicted Meehan after deliberating less than half an hour.

Ten years later, inside a newly filed criminal appeal, Harris says his testimony was all a lie. Meehan believes it should change the decision that put him in prison for the rest of his life."All these years I've explained to them that one day the truth is going to come out and there's going to be some surprised people," said Meehan. "That's what I hope this is."

"He (Kimbrough) said you do this for us and we will help you," Harris said on a recorded phone call last year from jail included in the court documents. "They had a case, but it was very weak. He said he need a conviction and he needed it bad."Harris has been a career criminal before and after his testimony 10 years go.

Now, Harris says not only did he lie about Meehan's murder confession, Harris describes specific meetings with Kimbrough and his investigators that helped fabricate his testimony.

"He elaborated that he was new in his career as district attorney and this would make him look real good in everyone's eyes," Harris said on the recorded call. "It was his first murder trial and he wanted a conviction."Harris claims Kimbrough's team met with him in the DA's office for two hours and spelled out specific details of the crime. Harris claims they even told him exactly what to say.

"They said to make it even sweeter, that I want you to put in one last detail. He said, 'I want you to look dead at the jury and tell them that Danny told you, if he couldn't have her, then nobody else could have her,'" he said.

Court papers show three of Harris' relatives say Harris also told them about making up the jailhouse confession.

Records show Harris was released from jail days after his testimony. The charges against him were dismissed."When the prosecutor put Gary Harris on the stand, he said you can't take a check from this guy, but you can believe what he's saying here today," Meehan said. "I'm curious what John Kimbrough would say now."

Kimbrough initially told us the evidence was strong enough even without Harris' jailhouse testimony. However, Kimbrough later denied repeated requests from Local 2 Investigates for an interview.

Local 2 legal analyst Brian Wice says Harris' testimony itself does bring up serious questions."My take in almost three decades of practicing criminal defense law is that you see jail house snitches by and large when the prosecution has to throw a 'Hail Mary', when they have a borderline case," Wice said. ...

Despite the recanted testimony, Wice and other legal experts we spoke with say the chances of a court ordering a new trial is slim.They all say it usually take new physical evidence like DNA or fingerprints to be convincing enough to force a new hearing.

Meehan's appeal has been denied by Kimbrough's office and the trial judge in his original case. Meehan's appeal is now sitting with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.
It's unsurprising Meehan can't find relief in this instance, which raises broader questions about whether adequate access to the courts exists for innocent people who've been wrongfully convicted. Without DNA evidence to back up Harris' recantation, the law seldom allows people in Meehan's position another bite at the apple. Indeed, before 2001 when the Lege established rights to post-conviction DNA testing, even those cases had trouble making it back into court. But we know the same kinds of faulty evidence were used in cases, like Meehan's, where no DNA evidence exists.

Given what we know about how and how often innocent Texans are convicted, the current system is too restrictive on non-DNA based writs alleging actual innocence. That aspect of the law needs significant changes to be fair to the falsely convicted. Virginia recently created such a process and its first actual innocence writ in a non-DNA case was granted in August.

Regarding jailhouse snitches, the Justice Project recently came out with a study (pdf) on the problem and suggested these reforms, all of which would require legislative action:

The Justice Project’s Recommendations for Improving
Standards for Admissibility of Accomplice and Snitch Testimony
  • Required mandatory, automatic pretrial disclosures of information related to jailhouse snitch testimony, including witness compensation arrangements and other information bearing on witness credibility.
  • Mandated pretrial hearings on the reliability testimony in cases where the prosecution intends to employ a jailhouse snitch.
  • A requirement that jailhouse snitch testimony be corroborated.
  • Cautionary jury instructions alerting the jury to the reliability issues presented by snitch testimony.

Monday, September 15, 2008

FBI: US crime down overall in 2007

The FBI issued its annual report on crime data today; see their web page devoted to the new data. Let's walk through a few highlights from the topline numbers. Bottom line, reported crime last year was down across the board:
Nationwide, violent crime fell for the first time since 2005. Property crime declined for the fifth straight year. And each of the seven specific offense categories—from aggravated assault to murder—was down from 2006.
DOJ created this graphic analyzing this year's overall crime trends:


It should be mentioned that national crime data are fairly flawed. Not all information gets reported. And year to year fluctuations may not mean much or necessarily depict a long-term trend. Still, less crime reported on its face must be be considered good news.

Though crime rates are declining overall, it's not necessarily because police are solving more crimes. Clearance rates remained low: "Nationwide in 2007, law enforcement cleared 44.5 percent of violent crimes and 16.5 percent of property crimes by arrest or exceptional means." The highest clearance rate was for murder, at 61.2% nationwide. Here's a graphic depicting clearance rates for various crimes:


I was also interested to learn that the vast majority of arrests are not for violent or property crimes: "In 2007, the FBI estimated that 14,209,365 arrests occurred nationwide for all offenses (except traffic violations), of which 597,447 were for violent crimes, and 1,610,088 were for property crimes. That means just 15.54% of arrests were for violent crimes or property offenses, a figure which seems surprisingly low to me.

Some of that can be explained by the drug war: "Law enforcement made more arrests for drug abuse violations (an estimated 1.8 million arrests, or 13.0 percent of the total number of arrests) than for any other offense." What's more, 42.1% of drug arrests were for pot possession.

Murder in large cities was predictably higher than the suburbs - towns with more than 100,000 people had a murder rate of 4.7 per 100,000, compared with 2.9 per 100,000 in towns with 25,000 to 99,999 people. But murder rates in the smallest towns were higher still, the FBI reports, with towns under 25,000 having a murder rate of 5.5 per 100,000. That also seems like a surprising outcome. Overall, 87% of murder victims knew their killer.

Texans reported 1,172 murders in 2007 and 6,853 forcible rapes, 79,103 auto thefts, and 181,502 home burglaries. See this table for city by city index crime details.

There's a lot more information and fodder for commentary in this annual report for those interested.

MORE: TalkLeft looks at the numbers and informs us that " contrary to the notion often expressed by crime warriors that there is less crime because more offenders are locked up, this Justice Policy Institute factsheet (pdf) shows the opposite: Areas with lower incarceration rates experienced greater crime reductions."

TYC commitments to grow dramatically despite declining juvie crime

Having analyzed on Saturday the Legislative Budget Board's incarceration projections for the adult prison system, let's take a look at LBB's projections regarding youth crime and incarceration in their five year population estimate (pdf) which is used to set agency budgets.

Regular readers know that in 2007 the Legislature took steps aimed at reducing inmate populations at the Texas Youth Commission, including shifting 19-20 year olds to TDCJ and refusing to take misdemeanants at state youth prisons. The population drop can be seen most dramatically in the number of releases. TYC released 4,375 inmates during fiscal year 2007, up from 3,554 in fy 2006. By comparison, the number of new inmates entering TYC decreased from 3,462 in fy 2006 to 2,994 in fy 2007 and an estimated 2,090 in 2008 (based on the monthly rate for the first seven months). LBB predicts the new level of intakes will hold steady at 2,090 over the next five years.

Those declines mainly represent implementation of a new law disallowing judges from sending misdemeanants to TYC, reduced lengths of stay, and reduced numbers from a handful of counties that essentially quit sending kids to the agency. Indeed, the reduced numbers allowed TYC to meet minimum staffing requirements for the first time in years.

On its face, TYC's reduced inmate population seems like it might be sustainable, particularly given that juvie crime is declining: "Texas juvenile arrest rate decreased between calendar years 2005 and 2006 (1.3 percent) following a decrease between calendar years 2004 and 2005 (8.3 percent)." Not only are arrests down, says LBB, Texas' overall juvie population is growing at a slower rate than in the past.

Even so, TYC's reduced inmate population will be shortlived unless more is done to reform the system. Today TYC operates at 6.5% below maximum capacity, and will slightly exceed max capacity in fy 2009, says LBB. But it's what happens after that which made me sit up and take notice. LBB predicts TYC's inmate population will resume fairly rapid growth in the near term, rising to 13.5% above apacity by 2010 and shooting up to 23.3% above capacity in 2012.

So the situation is this: Juvie crime is declining but total commitments to TYC will increase by about a quarter over the next four years as the agency's inmate population creeps back up toward their previous, higher levels. By contrast, LBB projects the increase in Texas' juvie probation population will be de minimus over the same period, with the number of juvie probationers overall expanding just .03% annually.

These data have significant implications for proposed TYC reforms. For starters, those like Sen. John Whitmire proposing the agency's abolition will be chagrined to see projections indicating a greater dependence on youth prisons going forward, not less of one.

That said, the adult system predicted massive overcrowding just a couple of years ago, and as discussed Saturday. reforms implemented by Sen. Whitmire and his colleagues staved off that increase for the foreseeable future by expanding treatment and diversion programs. They could do the same for TYC, but according to these data, changes implemented in 2007 failed to resolve the agency's crowding problems long term.

Sunday, September 14, 2008

Waiting for word on 1,000+ stranded at Galveston jail (Updated)

Still no word on what happened with the 1,000 inmates and their jailers stranded at the Galveston County jail during Hurricane Ike. Perhaps we may find small comfort in the notion that if full-blown tragedy had struck there it would likely have been reported by now.

However, I can still find no report from any media outlet on the stranded inmates written after the storm passed. Things must be quite a mess right now. Did the jail flood? If so, how badly? What happened at the peak of the storm?

I'm sure their electricity is out. How about potable water? Toilets? How are they being fed? Was anyone hurt? Were there any health crises during or after the storm? The Sheriff reportedly only left behind a skeleton crew to manage these responsibilities.

Did the Sheriff stay at the jail himself or just abandon his deputies and inmates and skedaddle? For that matter, did all the assigned deputies stay, or did they abandon their posts and leave the prisoners behind as happened during Katrina?

There are so many unanswered questions. Any reader with information or who sees news coverage on the topic please let us know in the comments.

Let's hope that the storm's last minute shift in course, which spared the island from Ike's greatest fury, also kept folks in the jail safe. But I'm thinking this dastardly decision cannot be allowed to stand as precedent.

After every major emergency like this we learn things that allow laws and policies to be adjusted heading into the next incident. For example, after guns were confiscated from New Orleans residents post-Katrina leaving law abiding folks at the mercy of looters and criminals, the 80th Texas Legislature passed a statute insisting that law enforcement could not confiscate weapons during an emergency.

There will be similar lessons to be learned from Hurricane Ike during the 81st Texas Legislature next spring, and one of them should definitely be to formally require jails in mandatory evacuation areas to evacuate their inmates, especially when they're kept on the first floor as is apparently the case in Galveston. TDCJ does it, and their prisoners are a lot bigger security risk than county jail inmates.

UPDATE: Good news! A Dailykos diarist who picked up the story refers us to IngeniousGirl who brings this report:

I just talked to Deputy at the jail - here is what I learned. ... The Deputy would not give me her name, but she told me that the inmates are safe ...

Plenty of heat, food, water, and the facility is 2 years old and is safe

She also said, the jail is not flooded.

All's well that ends well, but this was still a terrible judgement by the Sheriff that shouldn't be allowed in the future. Buildings can be constructed that withstand hurricane force winds, but on barrier islands like Galveston, flooding is the biggest danger. Everyone who chose to stay, including the jailers and inmates left behind, must count themselves lucky the storm shifted course at the last minute. If it hadn't the jail could have become the site of a serious tragedy.

NUTHER UPDATE (9/15): Here's the first MSM report letting us know everybody at the jail got by okay.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

LBB: Texas' prison population will dip next year for the first time in decades before rising further

Ever since the Governor fired Dr. Tony Fabelo and abolished the state's independent criminal justice number crunchers, the Texas Legislative Budget Board assumed responsibility for issuing population projections for the adult and juvenile justice systems. These are the official data on which state agencies base their budget requests and legislative budget writers authorized the expenditure of tax dollars for the Department of Criminal Justice and the Youth Commission.

See the latest projections here (pdf - June 2008). To me this is a fascinating and useful document, and a truly interdisciplinary one. LBB has to pull data from all sorts of different agencies and sources to produce these estimates, and the methodology sections are essentially a prose description of the mathematical reasoning contained in the main section.

Prior to the 80th Legislature, LBB projected the adult system might be as much as 17,000 beds short by 2012, prompting an aggressive commitment of new funds by the Lege to divert offenders away from prison and stave off new prison building, especially since the state cannot adequately staff the facilities we've got. According to the June 2008 analysis, Texas' total prison population will actually decline slightly next year (!) for the first time in many moons because of the 2007 probation/diversion reforms, eliminating the short-term need for expensive new prison building. The total will then begin to creep back up slightly, said LBB, which projects Texas will exceed current capacity by .6% in 2013 if nothing changes, needing to find 942 more beds instead of 17,000. (Thanks Jerry Madden and John Whitmire!)

Both parole and probation revocations are down thanks the the Legislature's expansion of treatment options and intermediate sanctions facilities, LBB reports. Statewide, in FY 2007, 7.5% of felony probationers and 9.7% of parolees were revoked back to prison, which compares favorably, e.g., to revocation rates of 8.8% and 14.8%, respectively, in 2004. (Regular readers know, of course, that such gains vary widely from county to county.)

Interestingly among LBB's assumptions, just 50% of those placed in new diversion beds are assumed to be people who'd otherwise be revoked to prison. That means the Lege has created a true intermediate sanction. It's not just a program that's LESS harsh than prison, for half of those using diversion beds it's actually a HARSHER sanction than would otherwise be available.

So where does the upward pressure on incarceration come from in Texas' adult prison system? For starters, Texas recently has averaged a 6% annual growth rate recently in direct court commitments to prison, said LBB, this compared to about 2.5% annual population growth statewide over the same period. LBB's numbers assume that high rate of increase will continue. This is true, they say, even though "The crime rate declined from its peak in 1988 and has remained steady at a lower level since 2000."

Another big driver of Texas'expanding prison population is the oxymoronically named "Discretionary Mandatory Supervision" statute, which requires just a bit of explanation for the uninitiated. Prior to 1996, offenders were automatically released when their served time and good time added together equalled their sentence. The Lege eliminated mandatory release, creating the bizarrely named DMS system that still requires a parole panel to approve offenders' release. These offenders - who prior to 1996 would have all been out the door - today are released only 52.2% of the time a parole panel considers them. That means almost half of offenders who would earlier have been eligible for mandatory release are today kept in prison by the parole board.

Overall, the parole approval rate averaged over the last 5 years was 28.7%, though in FY 2009 that ticked up to 29.9%. However a bigger factor has been a slow but significant increase in the number of parolees considered for approval - with that expansion, the number of approved paroles has increased slightly, said LBB, even though the overall approval rates didn't rise that much.

In the past, LBB's projections were used like a hammer to demand approving construction of unnecessary new prison beds. These projections won't have the same usefulness to prison builders. They show diversion programs worked, that investing in them reduced reliance on prisons and created meaningful alternatives that courts are actually using.

Coming Soon: I'll discuss LBB's juvie projections and the surprising increase they predict in TYC's inmate population.

Friday, September 12, 2008

Hubris: Galveston Sheriff leaves inmates, deputies, in hurricane's path

Galveston Island residents were told to flee Hurricane Ike or face "certain death," but the Sheriff has inexplicably decided not to evacuate 1,000 prisoners from the county jail, even though serious flooding has already begun.

It's bad enough to risk the inmates' lives, but downright bizarre to me that the Sheriff is willing to risk his deputies. The National Hurricane Center has predicted waves that will top Galveston's seawall potentially by several meters, which would easily flood the town. Take a look at these scary projections of how much flooding might occur if Ike does its worst.

"We did this during (Hurricane) Rita (in 2005) and no one knew until it was absolutely done," said a Sheriff's spokesman. Of course, Rita didn't hit Galveston Island directly and there was never a serious risk that it would breach the seawall. By contrast, with Ike still two hundred miles away, the surge has already raised water levels more than five feet, with 25 foot surges expected.

In 1900, more than 8,000 people died on Galveston Island after a major hurricane (pictured). The Sheriff is definitely tempting fate to take such a risk.

UPDATE (9/13): The Galveston Daily News reported last night before the storm fully hit quoting a mother who'd spoken to her son in the jail:
“He said, ‘Mom. I’m worried, scared and hungry. All of us are here cramped into this little room on the first floor. The flood waters are rising and we’re not going to evacuate.’”

Nuzzo said her son didn’t see water in the jail, but heard it was rising on the island.

“I called but they’re not answering the phones. It’s ludicrous they left the inmates there.”

Tuttoilmondo said the jail is primarily one level. Its phones were ringing all day
So from this we learn that the jail is a one-story structure, while most of the people who stayed in Galveston lived on the second or third floor, which is why they thought they'd survive widespread flooding. Besides, those folks chose to stay; inmates were put in this situation by the Sheriff. The whole thing sounds like a recipe for disaster potentially worse, even, than the abandonment of thousands of prisoners in the New Orleans jail during Katrina.

The Sheriff's decision tees me off the more I think about it. If he didn't stay at the jail himself along with the prisoners and the deputies he left behind, the man frankly should be run out of town on a rail when the Hurricane is past.

I checked the most recent (Aug. 1) Galveston jail population report (pdf) which showed 1009 inmates at that time, about the same number in the jail now. The majority of them, 653, hadn't yet been convicted but were sitting in jail awaiting trial; 264 of those were charged with a misdemeanor or state jail felonies (low level drug and property crimes). The Sheriff said these prisoners couldn't be moved for security reasons, but that's a bogus claim. The truth is he could have RELEASED most of them without harming security.

NUTHER UPDATE: Officials announced at 9:30 p.m. last night that there was no Ike-related loss of life, but I can't find any reports mentioning the jail from after when the bulk of the storm hit. I found some tidal data for Galveston showing the surge - nearly eight feet above normal levels around 3 a.m. - has gone back down, thank heavens. But that's high enough to risk drowning inmates on the first floor if those floodwaters reached the jail. What security concerns could justify such a risk?

AND MORE: Still no word on the jail. There was an earlier report that six feet of water surged into the county courthouse next door, but this morning CNN reports "
The storm flooded the historic district with 7 feet of water, which has since subsided to 4 feet, according to a Galveston county official. A foot of water flooded the city's main courthouse, where many people rode out the storm." If folks in the courthouse are okay, that's also a good omen, one would think, for the stranded jail inmates. Other areas of Galveston were harder hit. According to the New York Times:

[Fire] Chief Varela said flooding in the city was from 8 to 10 feet deep in some areas. On the way to a fire that his department couldn’t reach, he said he saw a pickup truck that had water over its roof.

“The low-lying neighborhoods are extremely flooded right now,” he said.

STILL NO WORD: As of this morning, Governor Perry's spokespers said she "did not know about any Ike-related deaths and did not have any information about inmates at a jail on Galveston that was not evacuated."